Shoppers will find Walnut Creek Cheese nestled amongst the many farms in Amish Country. It sits on land from the original farm established by the first Amish settler in the center of the world’s largest Amish settlement. The store strives to offer items that showcase the hard work and integrity of local Amish and Mennonite people. 

Walnut Creek Cheese makes it a mission to offer delicious foods at a great value. They put the natural in organic. From bulk foods to fresh meats and cheeses, fresh is at the top of the list for each product.  

The entire store is a unique shopping experience. There’s a fresh foods section, a gift items area, an eatery and a kitchenware section that sells kitchen accessories that are both decorative and functional. Nostalgic and antique items the owner has collected over the years adorn the entire store. 

Take a break from shopping to enjoy a fresh made lunch at the Mudd Valley Café and Creamery located inside the store. And, top off lunch with a bowl of ice cream, or an apple dumpling.

Make sure to visit the Copper Kettle Cannery section to see the tower of canned goods. You’ll find Apple Butter Barbecue Sauce that goes great over pork chops or the hot pepper relish you can serve over cream cheese and with crackers. There’s also a large selection of cookbooks such as the Cooking with the Horse and Buggy People. 

Walnut Creek Cheese offers a complete shopping experience all under one roof.

CONTACT Walnut Creek Cheese